I think it’s safe to say every homeowner remembers their first Halloween at their home.Having Trick or Treaters is like a home ownership rite of passage. After having a self debate in the candy aisle about how many Trick or Treaters will actually come and how much of the candy you will end up sneaking before the 31st, the next most important decision is what sweet treat to actually give out. There are SO many decisions and believe me kids remember which houses give out the best candy on the block. I always remembered to stop by the house that handed out movie sized boxes…I may have even stopped by that house twice one Halloween. So don’t be the house that gives out pencils or tooth brushes because your Trick or Treaters will walk away looking like our friend here:

In order to be the coolest house on the block we thought it would be fun to have you tell us what the ultimate Halloween candy is. We polled our office and these are the top 16 suggestions which we’ve ranked in the bracket above. Please stop back each week to vote for your favorite in each round of the candy face offs. We will announce the winning choice Monday, October 26th, just in time for you to stock up on the people’s choice. Cast your vote below in the first round of our Halloween Candy Royale:

ROUND 1

 Loading ...

Image of disappointed trick or treater courtesy of squidoo.com

The trademarks and trade dress of the above products are owned by their respective owners.