How to Choose the Best Type of Mortgage for You

In the second post in a three-part series about deciphering mortgages, Coldwell Banker Real Estate Market Specialist Les Christie explains how to pick a mortgage rate and term that suits your financial needs.

Choosing the right mortgage rate can be difficult. There are many different options, and what’s the best choice for one person may not be for another. When borrowers begin the mortgage process, they first need to develop an understanding of mortgage rates. Then, the challenge becomes identifying what type of mortgage meets their individual needs. Here are two questions every home buyer should ask themselves when choosing a mortgage rate:

  1. Do I want a fixed rate or adjustable rate mortgage (ARM)?

Borrowers have a choice of two types of loans, fixed rate or adjustable. In short, fixed rates mean the monthly payments never change. ARMs offer fixed rate terms for, usually, five or seven years followed by rates that can change once a year after that.

Fixed versus adjustable

“I’m a big fan of fixed rate mortgages,” said Greg McBride, chief financial analyst for, a leading mortgage loan information site. “For home buyers, it’s the best gauge of affordability. If you can’t afford a home with interest rates at below 4%, you can’t afford a home.”

ARMs are cheaper initially: At recent interest rates, the monthly payment for an ARM would save about $60 a month on a 30-year fixed with a $200,000 principal. But for many borrowers, that may not be enough savings to offset the uncertainty of potential adjustments.

For others, however, adjustable rate loans can make sense, according to Keith Gumbinger of, a mortgage information provider. “ARMs work well with short-term forms of ownership,” he said. “If you think you’ll be there only five or six years, ARMs will save you money.”

Other candidates for ARMs are households whose incomes are likely to rise, such as a one-income household with a partner who plans to return to the work force in a couple of years. They could opt for a more affordable payment during the lean times, knowing that, when their costs rise, they’ll be in a better financial position to afford the higher payments.

  1. If I have a fixed rate mortgage, should I choose a 30-year or 15-year?

The shorter the term of the fixed rate mortgage, the lower the interest rate, but the higher the monthly payments. On a $200,000 loan, a 15-year fixed at current rates will cost about $1,376 a month, $460 more than the payments on a 30-year mortgage.

Of course, the loan will be paid off in half the time, saving borrowers more than $80,000 in interest over the full course of the mortgage.

According to McBride, borrowers should opt for 15-years only when they can afford to do so without harming their other financial goals.

“Handcuffing yourself to higher monthly payments is bad if it prevents you from investing in tax-advantaged retirement accounts or if you’re unable to set aside enough cash in an emergency fund,” he said.

If you can’t max out your 401(k) payments because your mortgage payments are too steep, you’ll end up costing yourself a lot of money in the long run.

But if you’re convinced that you have enough income and savings, then go for the 15-year. You may be the first one on your block to be mortgage-free.

In our third and last installment of this series, we’ll look at other money-saving tips and tricks that could help you shave down the cost of your mortgage or even get ahead on a few payments. Stay tuned!

Les is a Real Estate Market Specialist for Coldwell Banker Real Estate.

Born and raised in Whitestone, N.Y., and never having lived outside of NYC, Les is a graduate of City College of New York in Manhattan. Les switched careers in his late 30s, studying writing at New School and Brooklyn Polytechnic, now the New York University Polytechnic School of Engineering. Les has written for several magazines and copyedited books on early childhood education prior to joining CNNMoney as a personal finance writer, where his main beat was real estate. His wife and partner of 42 years is a retired magazine editor who spent her career at the New York Zoological Society (Bronx Zoo). They are residents of the Upper West Side.

Subscribe to Blue Matter and get the latest updates


  1. business continuity plan pdf
    March 25, 2016

    Secondly, by following a risk based testing method to enterprise
    continuity, this highlights the areas not to check, bby prioritising the principle dangers to enterprise and therefore identifying
    areas of negliigible or zero danger.

  2. Maggie Allen
    June 8, 2016

    I really like the idea of using an ARM when you know that you won’t own the property for a very long time. Like you said, ARMs tend to be cheaper initially, and the opportunity for the rates to increase would be stunted. Plus, if you mentioned something like that to your mortgage broker, then they would probably be able to find you a good rate that won’t increase much over those 5-6 years as well.


Leave a Reply

Share on Facebook Share on Twiiter Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on WhatsApp Share on Telegram Share on Email